Caitlin Daugherty: Top Realtor in St. Augustine
Meet Caitlin Daugherty: Top Realtor in St. Augustine
Real Estate Excellence Podcast Episode 182
If you're searching for a real estate agent in St. Augustine who truly gets it, meet Caitlin Daugherty of One Sotheby's International Realty. In episode 182 of the Real Estate Excellence Podcast, I sat down with Caitlin to unpack her journey, her approach, and her hard-earned success in one of Florida's most dynamic markets.
Why Caitlin Stands Out in St. Augustine Real Estate
Caitlin isn’t just another agent. She’s a force. With nearly a decade of experience and a background running multiple bars and restaurants, she brings unmatched grit, adaptability, and client-first service to every deal. She's sharp, knowledgeable, and incredibly personable—but don’t mistake her kindness for weakness. Caitlin is a fierce negotiator who never backs down when it comes to advocating for her buyers and sellers.
Her clients love her for being a straight shooter, and so do I. She says what needs to be said, and she always backs it up with the facts and the market data. In an industry filled with fluff, Caitlin’s honesty and authenticity are a breath of fresh air.
Why Buyers Love Working with Caitlin
Relocating to St. Augustine? Caitlin knows exactly how that feels. She made the move herself and understands what it’s like to be the new kid on the block. That’s why she goes above and beyond to help buyers not just find a home—but understand the lifestyle, neighborhoods, and long-term value of the area. Her background in hospitality shines through in her white-glove service and deep care for every client’s journey.
Caitlin thrives on nurturing long-term buyer relationships. If you're 6–12 months out, she’s already mapping out a plan and educating you on the market. Whether it’s navigating historic districts, flood zones, or construction types, Caitlin has the local expertise you need.
Why Sellers Trust Caitlin to Deliver
If you’re looking to sell your home in St. Augustine, Caitlin will tell you the truth—even if it’s not what you want to hear. She believes in full transparency, thorough market analysis, and creating a standout listing strategy that includes professional photos, video, staging, and more. And when it comes to negotiations, she’s the kind of agent you want in your corner.
She doesn't just throw a sign in the yard—she crafts a strategy that moves properties. And she's not afraid to tell potential sellers when it's not the right time to list. That kind of integrity is rare.
What I Admire Most
I always enjoy talking to Caitlin. She’s a straight shooter with a deep love for real estate and for helping people. Whether she’s educating a first-time buyer or helping a seasoned investor, her passion for the business shines through. I’m proud of everything she’s accomplished, and I have no doubt there’s more greatness ahead for her.
Watch the Full Episode
🎥 Watch Caitlin's full episode here: https://youtu.be/GpVDdcmraLI
🎧 Listen and follow the Real Estate Excellence Podcast on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, and Spotify
🔗 Connect with Caitlin:
Explore more top agents and episodes:
👉 www.topjacksonvilleagents.com
👉 www.topstaugustineagents.com
👉 www.bestrealtorsjacksonville.com
👉 www.bestrealtorsstaugustine.com
👉 www.usedeli.com
👉 AI Home Search
FAQ
Who is the best realtor in St. Augustine, Florida?
Caitlin Daugherty stands out as one of the most skilled and trusted agents in St. Augustine, known for her honesty, service, and market expertise.
Is now a good time to sell my house in St. Augustine?
It depends on your goals. Caitlin provides honest guidance to determine if it’s the right move based on current market trends.
What should buyers relocating to St. Augustine know?
From historic charm to modern builds, Caitlin helps you understand neighborhood vibes, construction differences, flood zones, and school districts.
Pamela Hoffman: Top Realtor in Nocatee & Ponte Vedra
